Review: Working for the Devil (Dante Valentine, #1) by Lilith Saintcrow

Working for the Devil (Dante Valentine, #1)Working for the Devil by Lilith Saintcrow
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Okay, the long and short of it is that up until the last probably twenty pages I disliked this book, to a degree. No. Not true. I loathed it. Fiercely. The character development was not going very well and I was annoyed at how opaque the world-building and backstory were.

At 9% I was like “Ugh hope this gets better.” At 40% I was like “WHY WON’T SHE EXPLAIN ANYTHING OR LIKE, BE NICE TO HER FRIENDS?????” and now, at 69% I am just ultra baffled at why anyone would say this book is paced well and isn’t harboring a grudge against the editor that could have made it SO SO GOOD with very few well chosen suggestions. I will never again criticize info dumps. I will cherish them.

But then love story and glorious action. Stakes high enough. Realistic consequences. Tragedy.

This book still had a lot of flaws, but I was won over at the last minute. I guess all it takes to book-seduce me is to write me an unlikely romance and then kill off my favorite character. I have issues.

View all my reviews

Review: Lord’s Fall (Elder Races, #5) by Thea Harrison

Lord's Fall (Elder Races, #5)Lord’s Fall by Thea Harrison
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The best of Thea Harrison’s Elder Races books so far. Revisiting Dragos and Pia wasn’t at all tedious like I’d expected it to be. In fact, I liked both characters much more than I had when I read Dragon Bound. Maybe it was due to my familiarity with the world at this point – far less info dumping. However, it probably had more to do with the fact that both characters were more rational and less annoying. Dragos wasn’t stalkery-controlling (as much) and Pia wasn’t wimpy and….irritating.

The premise is that Dragos is staging a massive competition to replace two Sentinels, in the style of a set of gladiator-esque Games. There is something about competition brackets that I love. I can’t explain it but it probably has a lot to do with my also OCD obsession with lists. I live for lists.

Anyway, while this is happening the dragon’s mate, Pia, is traveling to the Elves to negotiate the end of a trade embargo. The embargo/trade parts (and really any of the practical business related bits) make no sense, but the book had to have some weaknesses. Everything else was pretty strong, including the cast of characters only just introduced in this book. There is even a pegasus. And a kraken for crying out loud. A KRAKEN. Stop it Thea Harrison. You are making me gushy about a romance novel that features pregnancy bits (vom). Stop it right now. p.s. next time moar kraken pls.

View all my reviews

Review: The House on Tradd Street (Tradd Street, #1) by Karen White

The House on Tradd Street (Tradd Street, #1)The House on Tradd Street by Karen White
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I am not really big on mystery novels. This is not to say I can’t enjoy a good mystery in a novel. I just cannot handle it when the entire plot of a novel revolves around not knowing a bunch of very important things. I also loathe really obvious foreshadowing and poorly dealt out clues. Of course, these things can all be present in non -genre novels too. What was I saying? Oh yeah, this book had a lot of issues, but I liked it. I’m a huge sucker for the Southern small town secretsy society old buildings charming culturey setting. Like, big time. Even though I would probably hate living in any of these places.

Despite the Southern charm; this book is rife with plot holes and grammatical issues that an editor shouldn’t have missed. The protagonist, Melanie Middleton, is not sympathetic. She is a prickly bitch who has a number of really good friends for no discernible reason. She is 39 and clearly has severe Obsessive Compulsive issues as a result of childhood trauma, but doesn’t seek professional help despite being accurately diagnosed by multiple people in her life. I actually respected that she didn’t own casual clothing. But the way she kept fobbing the dog off on other people was the kiss of death for her in my eyes. The fact that I am interested in reading the sequel defies as much logic as she does but whatever I do what I want.

View all my reviews

Review: The Casual Vacancy by J.K. Rowling

The Casual VacancyThe Casual Vacancy by J.K. Rowling
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Rowling really tapped into personal types of experience in this novel, whether they belonged to her or not, they were vivid and completely believable. I think her ability to create such credible points of view is what made the Harry Potter series so very good, her characters a very close to real, in that we might all know someone like them.

While I enjoyed reading this book, I can understand how slower readers might never gather any momentum with it. I do think it is worthwhile. It is very slice-of-life (chunk, more like). Very human. I can’t wait to see what she does next.

View all my reviews

Review: Quicksand by Nella Larsen Quicksand by Nella Larsen

QuicksandQuicksand by Nella Larsen
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I’m not sure how confident I am about the five stars just yet, this novel hit far too close to home. Quicksand is a bit like a modernist black Madame Bovary, if one wishes to be reductive, and I loved Madame Bovary.

Helga Crane is an unhappy schoolteacher at Naxos in Tennessee, chafing at the isolation and ostracization she feels being a bi-racial, class conscious woman in an all black institution in the South. She’s 23 at the opening of the novel. I am 23. Too close!

However, Helga lacks a home and sense of identity, her white mother, an immigrant from Denmark, died when Helga was fifteen, leaving her alone but for her Uncle Peter, a white man who arranges for her education but otherwise remains the racially correct amount of distant toward her. Helga’s father is absent but to my memory never finally accounted for. I presume he died when she was very young.

In the novel’s opening Helga decides suddenly after two years at Naxos she can’t bear another day of the place, quits without reference, breaks off her lukewarm engagement, and sets off to Chicago to apply to her Uncle Peter for a loan to get her on her feet. It’s the beginning of a journey for Helga, a quest for something she can’t define. Led astray by her own folly and inevitable inability to know her own mind, Helga searches for a home, an identity, and a balm to sooth the racial friction of her very being.

I read this novel for a literature class, and my classmate pointed out immediately how distasteful and unlikeable Helga is as a character. I may have to disagree, being that Helga is, for me, a caricature of possibility, a warning sign writ large. Likeable or not, she is the focal point of a series of very complex internalized issues, and a very interesting novel.

View all my reviews

Review: The Sparrow (The Sparrow, #1) by Mary Doria Russell

The Sparrow (The Sparrow, #1)The Sparrow by Mary Doria Russell
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

This novel is amazing. Probably the best Science Fiction novel I have ever read, and if not that, certainly in the top five. Hard-hitting theological questions detailed by tight knit interpersonal relationships and speculation about first contact with other sentient species. Very few flaws come to mind just after the first reading, but if I had to name one it would probably be how difficult it was to mentally picture Emilio Sandoz as a real human being, given how detailed his characterization is at the start, and how much he changes. I doubt it would trouble too many others. Though, speaking of troubling elements, this book is not fluffy and NOT for the faint of heart. Still, read it. READ IT.

View all my reviews

Review: Finnikin of the Rock (Lumatere Chronicles, #1) by Melina Marchetta

Finnikin of the Rock (Lumatere Chronicles, #1)Finnikin of the Rock by Melina Marchetta
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Whichever misgivings I had in the first few pages of this book, not enough concrete detail, or dialogue, or characterization, didn’t leave me throughout the rest.

It’s kind of like a slightly loose tooth you can stop jiggling with your tongue. Because you KNOW it’s there and you KNOW it’s loose and you just can’t.

The story is fine, but don’t expect to ever really be told how, why, or what about anything major. I.e. “the days of the unspeakable.” Jiggle.

There are a lot of characters and no real actual villain. Kind of like how you never actually see Sauron in LoTR. But less so, because Sauron is much more vivid than, um. What’s his name? That’s right. Jiggle.

The characters all, for the most part, have good and bad qualities. Physical characteristics? Kind of. Personal growth, sure, I guess. They don’t talk much, though.

All in all there were a lot of little things that could have been tightened up to make the whole narrative more cohesive. Like more dialogue…

I also had a suspicion the entire time that there was some “subtle” feminist subtext that didn’t show through because, well, it wasn’t working. It felt like a point was trying to be made that was kind of thrown in as an afterthought. (view spoiler)[I am mainly referring to Evanjalin being totally capable, but being forced into entirely unnecessary constraints despite her being more savvy and badass than any of the men. The part at the end when Finnikin had to realize their equality was a departure from the patriarchy though. Tiny applause. (hide spoiler)]

View all my reviews

Review: Faerie Tale by Raymond E. Feist

Faerie TaleFaerie Tale by Raymond E. Feist
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Having previously read Feist’s Riftwar Saga and giving it a solid meh, I can confidently say this is Feist at his best.

Fans of Neil Gaiman’s American Gods will enjoy this book, which was published about ten years before Gaiman’s exploration of the fantastical in different kinds of folk tales.

Great pacing, solid characters, masterful weaving of the paranormal and mystical elements. Loved it.

View all my reviews

Review: Oracle’s Moon (Elder Races, #4) by Thea Harrison

Oracle’s Moon by Thea Harrison
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

I admit I did some giggling and I liked this book, and liked Grace’s character, to an extent.

However I came into it expected a strong character like herself to be more independent. Really her salvation in the end came from a lot of convenient deus ex machina windfalls to make her life run more smoothly.

Plus there was that whole, “a man dropped into my life and now everything is great” and “omg you’re the best lover ever, you have mouths EVERYWHERE” thing.

I don’t know. Not a bad read, but not progressive or groundbreaking or particularly spellbinding in any way. Also, sparse plot.

But hey, it’s a romance novel.

View all my reviews

Review: Divergent (Divergent, #1) by Veronica Roth

Divergent (Divergent, #1)Divergent by Veronica Roth
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I had a moment about midway into reading this book where I looked up and remarked aloud (I wasn’t alone in the room, not that that would have stopped me) that all authors steal, you know? They all have and they all do, and the difference between my noticing Veronica Roth “stealing” where I generally haven’t often noticed other authors before is that probably I’m just not as well read in their influences, predecessors, competitors, what have you.

It’s weird and feels wrong to admit, but I like dystopian fiction. I only say that it’s weird and feels wrong because I don’t particularly want to like it, as the idea of a dystopian future has haunted my nightmares since I was forced to watch the movie The Road two years ago. It was an awful experience, I was terrified and disgusted. However, I have to admit I like it because I’ve read so much of it. Scott Westerfeld’s Uglies series, The Hunger Games, The Host (yes, even Stephenie Meyer), Ender’s Game, Margaret Petersen Haddix’s Among the Hidden. To name a few.

Throughout Roth’s attempt to amalgamate these elements and visuals I was forcibly reminded of elements of all of these other works. It made me feel both kind of bored and also ridiculously well-read in this genre. But let’s focus on the boredom.

I couldn’t care too much about Tris because it became clear very early that our tiny, non-pretty, speshul snowflake wasn’t really going to come to harm. I liked her, but I’ve read book after book about small white blonde girls against the world, and it’s really tired. I only say this having read all of Tamora Pierce’s Alanna novels, plus other short authors like Laurell K. Hamilton (who I manage to mention in every. single. review. How??? I’m obsessed, clearly). We get it. Fighting people bigger than you is hard and takes more work. Geez. I should write a book where the protagonist faces the perils of bumping her head, can’t ever find long enough pants, tall enough dates, and consistently knocks things over in close quarters. Because normal to tall people seem to be an underrepresented minority in fiction. Or maybe I’m just being silly. Who knows.

But let’s not get me started about the feasibility of the entire plot. Getting through this novel required a huge suspension of not only disbelief, but also, you know, reality. Physics. Psychology. You know. Stuff.

It’s just so unlikely that the response to world disorder is a big ol’ personality quiz segregation. I mean, people are stupid, but it just doesn’t stand up to logic. Virtue ethics are great measures of character, but they don’t dictate behavior the way Roth designed the society to work.

All in all it just didn’t live up to the hype. Roth is a great writer, but I’ll hold out until a different series/novel appears to give her another go.

View all my reviews